Water-To-Fuel Conversion: Energy's Future?

Water cannot be used as fuel, but it can be converted into fuel through a process called electrolysis, which uses electricity to split water into hydrogen and oxygen. Hydrogen is a fuel that can be used in engines such as hydrogen-powered cars. However, the energy released from burning hydrogen and oxygen is less than the energy used to split water, making the process inefficient. Additionally, hydrogen is highly explosive, posing safety concerns for its use in vehicles.

Electrolysis to separate water into hydrogen and oxygen

Electrolysis is a method of separating elements by pushing an electric current through a compound. In the context of water, electrolysis involves using electricity to split water into hydrogen and oxygen. This process occurs within a unit called an electrolyzer, which can vary in size from small, appliance-sized equipment to large-scale, central production facilities.

The electrolyzer, similar to a fuel cell, consists of an anode and a cathode separated by an electrolyte. The specific design and functionality of electrolyzers can vary depending on the type of electrolyte material used and the ionic species it conducts. Here's a more detailed look at the process:

Polymer Electrolyte Membrane (PEM) Electrolyzers

In this type of electrolyzer, the electrolyte is a solid specialty plastic material. Water reacts at the anode to form oxygen and positively charged hydrogen ions (protons). The electrons flow through an external circuit, and the hydrogen ions selectively move across the PEM to the cathode. At the cathode, the hydrogen ions combine with electrons from the external circuit to form hydrogen gas.

Alkaline Electrolyzers

Alkaline electrolyzers operate by transporting hydroxide ions (OH-) through the electrolyte from the cathode to the anode, with hydrogen being generated on the cathode side. These electrolyzers typically use a liquid alkaline solution of sodium or potassium hydroxide as the electrolyte and have been commercially available for many years. Newer approaches using solid alkaline exchange membranes (AEM) as the electrolyte are also being explored.

Solid Oxide Electrolyzers

Solid oxide electrolyzers employ a solid ceramic material as the electrolyte, which selectively conducts negatively charged oxygen ions (O2-) at elevated temperatures. Steam at the cathode combines with electrons from the external circuit to form hydrogen gas and negatively charged oxygen ions. The oxygen ions pass through the solid ceramic membrane, react at the anode to form oxygen gas, and generate electrons for the external circuit. Solid oxide electrolyzers require much higher operating temperatures compared to PEM and commercial alkaline electrolyzers.

While electrolysis is a promising option for carbon-free hydrogen production, it is important to note that it is not the most efficient method for obtaining hydrogen. The energy released from burning hydrogen and oxygen is necessarily less than the energy input required for electrolysis. Additionally, there are economic considerations, such as the explosive risk, the need for compression, metal embrittlement, and the cost of fuel cells.

Hydrogen as a fuel for cars

Hydrogen fuel-cell vehicles (HFCVs) are powered by electricity generated by combining hydrogen and oxygen in a fuel cell. While this technology is similar to electric vehicles (EVs), HFCVs differ in that they do not rely solely on batteries to provide electricity to the motor. Instead, they use hydrogen as a fuel source to generate electricity on-demand. This process only emits water vapour and warm air, making HFCVs a zero-emission vehicle option.

HFCVs use a fuel-cell stack to combine pure hydrogen (H2) with oxygen (O2) from the air, resulting in electricity and water vapour. This electricity then powers the electric motor that drives the vehicle's wheels. The fuel-cell stack acts as an energy carrier, converting the energy stored in hydrogen into electricity. The process is technically classified as a series hybrid, and HFCVs are sometimes referred to as fuel-cell hybrid electric vehicles (FCHEVs).

Benefits of Hydrogen Fuel-Cell Vehicles

One of the significant advantages of HFCVs is their efficiency. They are more efficient than conventional internal combustion engine vehicles and do not produce harmful tailpipe emissions. Additionally, HFCVs offer a faster refuelling time compared to EVs, taking only about five minutes to refuel, similar to traditional gasoline cars. The driving range of HFCVs is also impressive, with a range of more than 300 miles per refuelling.

Challenges and Limitations

One of the main challenges of HFCVs is the limited availability of hydrogen fuelling infrastructure. The number of hydrogen fuelling stations is relatively low, and ensuring a reliable supply of hydrogen fuel can be difficult. This issue has been particularly prominent in California, where an explosion disrupted the supply to several stations, causing significant disruptions for hydrogen vehicle owners.

Another limitation is the cost of hydrogen fuel. The small network of retail stations often charges high prices, making it more expensive to refuel an HFCV compared to traditional gasoline or electric vehicles. Additionally, servicing an HFCV can be specialised due to the high-pressure hydrogen tanks and fuel-cell stack, requiring dealership service centres with specific knowledge and equipment.

Examples of Hydrogen Cars

Since 2015, three hydrogen-powered cars have been offered for sale: the Honda Clarity Fuel Cell, the Hyundai Nexo SUV, and the Toyota Mirai. However, Honda has discontinued the Clarity, and Hyundai has sold a limited number of Nexo SUVs. Toyota remains the most committed to hydrogen power, with sales of the Mirai in the US, although they have also offered substantial discounts to attract buyers.

Hydrogen fuel enhancement

Research has been conducted on fuel mixtures, including gasoline and nitrous oxide injection, and results have shown a reduction in contamination from exhaust gases and, at times, a small increase in efficiency. However, to obtain significant results, modifications to the engine's air-fuel ratio, ignition timing, and emissions control systems may be required.

One example of hydrogen fuel enhancement is the Hydrogen-Enhanced Combustion Engine (HECE), which involves adding a small amount of hydrogen to the cylinder charge, allowing homogeneous charge ultra-lean-burn combustion engines to operate much leaner. This technology, developed by ArvinMeritor, IAV, and MIT, has the potential to improve gasoline fuel economy by 20-30%.

Another company, HyTech Power, has developed a retrofit technology called Internal Combustion Assistance (ICA) that adds tiny amounts of gaseous hydrogen and oxygen to the fuel before combustion. This technology claims to improve fuel efficiency by 20-30%, reduce particulate matter by 85%, and decrease NOx emissions by 50-90%.

While hydrogen fuel enhancement shows promise, it is important to note that it requires additional energy inputs to separate hydrogen from water, and the resulting hydrogen must be stored and converted back into energy. This process currently makes hydrogen fuel enhancement expensive and energy-intensive.

The steam car

The idea of powering a vehicle with steam is not a new one. In fact, plans for steam-powered vehicles date as far back as the 17th century. However, it is only recently that the idea has gained traction as a potential alternative to traditional internal combustion engines.

Steam-powered vehicles work through external combustion, which means that a fuel source is required outside the engine to produce the steam that propels the moving parts. This is in contrast to internal combustion engines, where fuel is burned inside the engine, and the explosion from the burning gasoline results in the pressure necessary to turn the moving parts.

One of the main advantages of steam-powered vehicles is their fuel flexibility. In the context of growing concerns around the world's dependence on fossil fuels, steam-powered engines offer a way to lessen that dependence. Any fuel can be used to kick-start the steam process, whether that's gasoline from petroleum or biofuel.

Another advantage of steam-powered engines is their potential for increased efficiency. While traditional steam engines were large and unwieldy, modern steam engines, such as those designed by Harry Schoell, are built on a closed-loop system of heating and cooling, which makes the engine much more efficient and produces less waste than previous models. Schoell's engines are also smaller and would fit easily into the footprint of a standard internal combustion engine.

However, there are also some challenges and disadvantages associated with steam-powered vehicles. One common misconception is that steam engines tend to explode. While this has been debunked by several sources, there are still valid concerns around the time it takes for a steam engine to build up enough power to drive from a cold start. Schoell's company, Cyclone Power Technologies, reports a time of 10 to 15 seconds for start-up, and full power in less than a minute, which is less time than a diesel engine requires to warm up.

Another potential issue with steam-powered vehicles is the safety and storage of fuel. For example, hydrogen, which can be derived from water through electrolysis, is highly explosive and would need to be safely stored in a vehicle to prevent accidents.

Despite these challenges, there is growing interest in the potential of steam-powered engines, particularly as public concerns around fossil fuel use continue to rise. Only time will tell if steam-powered vehicles will gain widespread adoption, but with their fuel flexibility and potential for increased efficiency, they could offer a viable alternative to traditional internal combustion engines.

Electric cars charged with hydroelectricity

Water-fuelled cars have been the subject of numerous international patents, news articles, and scientific publications. However, the laws of physics state that there is no way to extract chemical energy from water alone. Water is highly stable, and it requires energy to break its chemical bonds.

Most proposed water-fuelled cars rely on electrolysis to separate water into hydrogen and oxygen, which are then recombined to release energy. However, the laws of thermodynamics guarantee that the energy required to separate the elements will always be equal to or greater than the amount of energy released. Therefore, this process cannot be used to produce net energy.

Hydroelectricity is a form of renewable energy that generates electricity from the movement of water. This can be done through the use of dams and reservoirs, which store water and release it through turbines to generate electricity. This process can be used to charge electric cars, providing them with a source of power that is independent of fossil fuels.

However, it is important to note that the availability and reliability of hydroelectric power can vary depending on geographical location and weather conditions. The environmental impact of constructing dams and reservoirs for hydroelectric power generation may also be considered a disadvantage in certain contexts.

In conclusion, while water cannot be used as a direct fuel source, electric cars can be indirectly powered by water through the use of hydroelectric power generation. This provides a renewable and emission-free energy source for electric vehicles, contributing to a more sustainable transportation system.

Frequently asked questions