Wheel Size Impact: Fuel Economy And Performance

The wheel size of a vehicle can have a significant impact on its fuel economy. While larger wheels can improve the appearance and performance of a car, they also come with certain trade-offs. As the diameter of the wheel increases, the size of the tire's sidewall must decrease to maintain the overall tire diameter, which is crucial for accurate speedometer readings and gearing. This change in tire dimensions can lead to a reduction in fuel efficiency, as larger wheels are heavier and require more energy to rotate. Additionally, the width of the tires may also increase with larger wheels, resulting in wider tires with shorter and stiffer sidewalls. These factors collectively contribute to a decrease in fuel economy, with some tests showing a 10% drop in fuel efficiency when moving from 15-inch to 19-inch wheels.

Smaller wheels are more fuel-efficient

Larger tires decrease fuel economy because they are heavier, while smaller tires increase fuel efficiency. Bigger tires also have a higher rolling resistance than smaller tires, which means they require more resistance and effort to get them rolling. Rolling resistance is how the tire overcomes inertia. It is defined as the measure of force at the axle in the direction of travel required to make a loaded tire roll. So, in stop-start traffic, the smaller tire would be the better option because less power is needed so it will get better mileage.

The size of the wheels also impacts the weight of the vehicle. Smaller wheels are usually lighter, which minimizes the car's resistance. However, it is important to note that opting for a lighter wheel may affect the types of tires that can be used, potentially trading off some fuel efficiency.

The type of tires used also plays a role in fuel efficiency. Tires with low rolling resistance use modern tread design and new materials to minimize the amount of gasoline or electricity required to move the car. Shallower treads, for instance, are more fuel-efficient than deeper ones.

In addition, the air pressure in tires can impact fuel economy. Tires with low air pressure will cause the rubber to bulge where it meets the pavement, creating more driving friction. This puts additional strain on the engine, leading to increased fuel consumption.

Larger wheels are heavier, reducing performance

While larger wheels may be aesthetically pleasing to some, they can hinder performance. In general, larger wheels are heavier, and this additional weight can negatively impact a vehicle's performance.

A heavier wheel will require more energy to turn, which can result in reduced acceleration and fuel economy. A test conducted by Car and Driver on a Volkswagen Golf found that there was a four-percent degradation in 0-to-60-mph acceleration from the smallest to the largest wheel size tested (15-inch to 19-inch wheels). The larger wheels also resulted in a 10-percent drop in fuel economy.

The impact of larger wheels on performance can be explained by Newton's Second Law, which states that the force on an object is equal to its mass multiplied by its acceleration. Therefore, increasing the wheel size and, consequently, the mass of the wheel, will result in a decrease in the driving force from the wheels, leading to reduced acceleration.

Additionally, as the wheel size increases, the tyre profile must decrease to maintain the same overall diameter. This means that the tyre sidewalls need to be stronger to withstand lateral forces during cornering, which can decrease ride comfort and feedback to the driver.

It is worth noting that the impact of wheel size on performance may vary depending on other factors such as the specific vehicle, engine specifications, and driving conditions. However, in general, larger wheels can hinder performance due to their increased weight and impact on tyre characteristics.

Larger wheels may increase grip

One of the most popular modifications done to cars is replacing the wheels. While larger wheels can improve grip and traction, they can also reduce performance.

Improved Grip and Traction

Larger wheels have more rubber on the tyre track, which increases the surface area in contact with the road. This results in better overall handling, especially when cornering and accelerating. In addition, the wider tread and stiffer walls of larger wheels can improve braking performance and reduce braking distances.

Increased Stability

The wider surface area of larger wheels also contributes to better stability for the vehicle. The improved grip on the ground allows the vehicle to withstand heavier loads.

Downsides

However, there are some downsides to larger wheels. Firstly, they can lead to higher fuel consumption due to the increased weight, which requires the engine to work harder. This can also result in heavier steering, increased wheel scraping, and faster tyre wear. Additionally, larger wheels can affect the accuracy of certain safety systems such as EBD, ABS, and traction control. They can also reduce ride comfort and increase vibration while driving.

Smaller wheels are better for acceleration

The relationship between wheel size and the force produced by the wheel is crucial to understanding this phenomenon. According to Newton's Second Law, the force acting on an object is equal to its mass multiplied by its acceleration. By applying a torque through the wheel's axis, a driving force is generated. When the wheel radius is increased, the driving force decreases, leading to reduced acceleration.

This principle is evident in the example of a car. A car's engine may struggle to rotate larger wheels, resulting in decreased acceleration. Car and Driver conducted a test using a VW Golf with varying wheel sizes, and the results confirmed that smaller wheels yielded faster acceleration times. The car with 15-inch wheels accelerated from 0 to 60 mph in 7.6 seconds, while the same car with 19-inch wheels took 7.9 seconds.

The impact of wheel size on acceleration is also observed in mountain biking. Smaller wheels, such as 26-inch or 27.5-inch wheels, accelerate faster than larger 29-inch wheels. This advantage in acceleration is attributed to the lower moment of inertia of smaller wheels, making them less challenging to get moving.

While smaller wheels offer improved acceleration, it is important to consider other factors that influence vehicle performance, such as grip, handling, and aesthetics. Increasing wheel diameter often leads to wider tyres, enhancing the grip between the tyre and the road. Additionally, larger wheels can contribute to a more aggressive and compact side profile, enhancing the overall appearance of the vehicle.

Tyre pressure impacts fuel efficiency

The air pressure in your tyres is a vital aspect of your car's performance and safety. It supports the entire weight of your car, and maintaining the correct tyre pressure is essential for keeping you and other road users safe, improving vehicle performance, decreasing fuel costs, and extending the life of your tyres.

Under-inflation

Under-inflated tyres are a leading cause of tyre failure. They cause more of the tyre to be in contact with the road, increasing friction and wear. This results in increased rolling resistance, which makes the engine work harder and leads to higher fuel consumption. Under-inflation also affects braking performance, increasing your vehicle's braking distance and compromising handling responsiveness.

A study by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) in the USA found a direct correlation between tyre pressure and fuel economy. Every 1% decrease in tyre pressure resulted in a 0.3% reduction in fuel economy. Therefore, a tyre under-inflated by 10% increases fuel consumption by 2%, and a 20% under-inflation increases fuel consumption by 4%.

Over-inflation

Over-inflated tyres give a bumpier ride and compromise handling. They also create uneven tread wear. Contrary to popular belief, over-inflation does not improve fuel economy.

Optimising Tyre Pressure for Fuel Efficiency

Maintaining the correct tyre pressure is crucial for balancing safety, performance, and fuel efficiency. It ensures optimal contact between the tyre and the road surface. The recommended tyre pressure for most vehicles is between 30 and 35 PSI, but this can vary depending on the vehicle's make and model. This information can be found in the owner's manual or on a sticker on the driver's side door jamb or glove box door.

It is recommended to check tyre pressure at least once a month, or before long trips, using a tyre pressure gauge. Regular checks will ensure your tyre pressure stays at the recommended level, improving fuel economy over time.

Frequently asked questions