Fuel Cells Vs Electric Cars: The Future Of Driving?

Hydrogen fuel cell vehicles (HFCVs) and battery electric vehicles (BEVs) are two promising technologies that could help reduce the transport industry's greenhouse gas emissions. HFCVs use electricity to power an electric motor, while BEVs rely solely on electrical power for their operation. HFCVs have several advantages over BEVs, including longer ranges, quicker refuelling times, and greater energy storage density. However, BEVs are currently more affordable and have more advanced infrastructure. So, will fuel cells replace electric cars? While HFCVs have the potential to become a viable commercial option, it is unlikely that they will surpass electric vehicle technology and replace electric cars in the near future.

Hydrogen fuel cells are more expensive than electric cars

Hydrogen fuel cell cars are more expensive than electric vehicles (EVs) and this is a major factor in why EVs are currently more popular. The two mainstream hydrogen cars on sale in the US, the Toyota Mirai and Hyundai Nexo, start at around $50,000 and $60,000 respectively. In comparison, a growing number of EVs cost less than this, thanks to the falling price of lithium-ion batteries.

Research by Sergey Paltsev, a senior research scientist at the MIT Energy Initiative, found that the total cost of ownership for hydrogen was about 10% more than an EV. This is largely due to the cost of hydrogen fuel, which has been priced at about $20 per kilogram, the energy equivalent of a gallon of gas. Recently, retail stations in California have been charging as much as $36 per kilogram.

Hydrogen-powered cars are also more expensive to refuel than EVs. It costs around $6 to $10 to recharge an EV battery, whereas the cost of refuelling a hydrogen gas tank varies from $75 to $125, depending on the fuel tank size.

Hydrogen fuel cell cars are also more expensive to maintain than EVs. This is due to the lack of moving parts in EVs, which means they are more reliable and require less maintenance, resulting in a lower overall cost.

The high cost of hydrogen fuel cell cars is a significant barrier to their widespread adoption and, currently, they are not a viable alternative to EVs for most consumers.

Hydrogen cars are quicker to refuel

The speed of refuelling is a significant advantage for hydrogen cars over electric vehicles. This is because refuelling a hydrogen car is a more familiar process for consumers used to petrol or diesel cars. Additionally, the time taken to refuel a hydrogen car is comparable to the time taken to refuel a traditional car, making the switch to hydrogen cars more appealing to consumers.

The refuelling process for hydrogen cars involves filling up a high-pressure tank with hydrogen gas. This tank is then used to power the car by converting the hydrogen gas into electric current, which powers the motor. The refuelling time for hydrogen cars is so quick because the hydrogen is pumped into the tank at high pressure, which can be done rapidly.

While electric cars can also be "refuelled" relatively quickly using fast-charging points, this is still a slower process than refuelling a hydrogen car. Additionally, electric cars often require a longer time plugged into a power source to reach a full charge, whereas hydrogen cars can be refuelled and ready to go in just a few minutes.

The speed of refuelling is a crucial factor in the debate over whether hydrogen cars could replace electric cars in the future. While hydrogen cars have the advantage of quicker refuelling, they also have several disadvantages, such as a lack of infrastructure and higher costs, that currently make them less viable than electric cars. However, as technology improves and infrastructure develops, it is possible that hydrogen cars could become more popular in the future.

Electric cars are more widely available

By 2024, it is forecasted that 25% of all new passenger car registrations will be electric, exceeding 17 million units in sales globally. This growth is projected to continue, with electric vehicles expected to make up 23.5% of the global light-vehicle market by 2025 and 45.3% by 2030.

In contrast, only a few hydrogen cars are available for purchase. The Toyota Mirai and Hyundai Nexo are the two mainstream hydrogen cars on sale in the United States, with starting prices of around $50,000 and $60,000, respectively.

The availability of electric vehicles varies across different countries. For example, in Norway, all-electric vehicles accounted for 80% of passenger vehicle sales in 2022, while in the United States, the figure was 6%. China is the largest market for electric cars, with 40% of total sales projected by 2030.

The widespread availability of electric vehicles is driven by technological advancements, environmental consciousness, and supportive government policies. The falling prices of lithium-ion batteries have also contributed to the increasing affordability and accessibility of electric vehicles.

The infrastructure for electric vehicles is also more established than for hydrogen fuel cell vehicles. A vast, nationwide electrical system already exists for electric vehicles, whereas hydrogen fuel cell vehicles would require the creation of a new infrastructure for refueling stations.

The cost of electric vehicles is generally lower than hydrogen-powered cars, making them more accessible to a wider range of consumers. The lifetime cost of ownership for a fuel cell car remains high due to the expense of hydrogen fuel.

In summary, electric cars are more widely available than hydrogen fuel cell vehicles due to their growing market, technological advancements, environmental initiatives, and cost-effectiveness.

Hydrogen cars are gaining popularity

The popularity of hydrogen cars is increasing due to several advantages over EVs. Firstly, hydrogen cars offer faster refuelling times, taking only a few minutes to refill, which is comparable to the experience of refuelling traditional gasoline cars. In contrast, charging an EV battery can take several hours. Secondly, hydrogen cars provide a more extended range on a single tank of fuel, allowing for longer distances to be travelled without the need for refuelling. This extended range is particularly attractive for long-haul trucking and commercial applications. Finally, hydrogen cars produce zero harmful emissions, making them a more environmentally friendly option.

Despite these advantages, hydrogen cars face several challenges that have prevented them from achieving widespread adoption. One of the main barriers is the high cost of ownership. Hydrogen cars tend to be more expensive than their EV counterparts, with prices starting at around $50,000 for the Toyota Mirai and $60,000 for the Hyundai Nexo, the two mainstream hydrogen cars currently available in the US market. The high cost of hydrogen fuel also contributes to the overall higher cost of ownership for hydrogen cars.

Another significant challenge for hydrogen cars is the lack of refuelling infrastructure. The limited number of hydrogen refuelling stations makes it inconvenient for consumers to refuel their vehicles, reducing the practicality of hydrogen cars. This issue is further compounded by the high cost of building and maintaining hydrogen refuelling stations, deterring potential investors and slowing down the development of the necessary infrastructure.

While hydrogen cars offer certain benefits, they also face other drawbacks, such as lower energy efficiency compared to EVs and complexities in the hydrogen production process. Additionally, the production of hydrogen can be energy-intensive and rely on non-renewable sources, which can impact their sustainability credentials.

In conclusion, while hydrogen cars are gaining some traction in the market, they have not yet achieved widespread popularity due to the challenges mentioned above. However, ongoing advancements and investments in hydrogen fuel cell technology could improve their viability in the future.

Electric cars have a vast, nationwide electrical system

The transition to electric vehicles on a nationwide scale is challenging, requiring a charging network and increased electricity generation. However, it is less challenging than building a new hydrogen economy. The creation of a hydrogen economy would require an enormous amount of hydrogen to be produced and transported to refueling stations across the country.

The availability of charging stations and the existing electrical grid make electric vehicles a more convenient and reliable option for consumers. The development of a hydrogen refueling network is still in its early stages, with a limited number of stations available, mainly in California and a few other countries.

The widespread adoption of electric vehicles is also supported by government incentives, making them more affordable for consumers. In contrast, hydrogen-powered cars are generally more expensive, with higher refueling costs.

The existing electrical system, combined with the decreasing cost of lithium-ion batteries, has made electric vehicles widely available and accessible to a large number of users. This accessibility and affordability contribute to the growing popularity of electric cars.

The vast, nationwide electrical system provides a solid foundation for the continued adoption of electric vehicles, offering a cleaner, more cost-effective, and energy-efficient alternative to traditional gasoline-powered vehicles.

Frequently asked questions