The Evolution Of Fuel: Lead Alternatives And Their Impact

Tetraethyllead (TEL) was added to gasoline beginning in the 1920s to reduce engine knock and help prevent valve-seat recession. However, by the 1950s, scientists discovered that TEL was toxic to humans, especially children, and the environment. As a result, regulators began phasing out TEL in the 1970s, and most countries had completely banned its use in gasoline by the early 2000s. Today, unleaded gasoline is the standard, and vehicles are designed with hardened valve seats that are more resilient to valve recession. For classic cars that were built with leaded gasoline in mind, lead substitutes are available that contain chemicals forming a sacrificial layer to inhibit microwelds and protect valve seats.

Tetraethyllead (TEL) was phased out due to its toxic effects on humans and the environment

Tetraethyllead (TEL) was widely used as a fuel additive for much of the 20th century, first being mixed with gasoline in the 1920s. TEL was added to gasoline to reduce engine knock and help prevent valve-seat recession. TEL massively raised the octane levels of gasoline, which allowed engine compression to be raised substantially, increasing vehicle performance and fuel economy.

However, in the mid-20th century, scientists discovered that TEL was toxic to humans, especially children, and the environment. TEL caused lead poisoning and was found to be harmful to the human brain. It was also discovered that TEL did not gel well with catalytic converters and could affect their function.

Due to its toxic effects, the use of TEL began to be phased out in the 1970s, with most countries completely banning it by the early 2000s. The state of California was the first to officially ban leaded fuel in 1992, and the United States banned leaded fuel for on-road vehicles in 1996. The last country to use TEL, Algeria, phased it out in July 2021, marking the end of leaded gasoline worldwide.

The phase-out of TEL has resulted in significant benefits for global health and the environment. A 2011 study backed by the United Nations estimated that the removal of TEL resulted in $2.4 trillion in annual benefits and 1.2 million fewer premature deaths. Additionally, the reduction in lead exposure has been linked to increased average IQ levels and decreased violent crime rates.

Unleaded fuel was introduced alongside hardened valve seats to prevent engine damage

The use of leaded fuel dates back to the 1920s, when car manufacturers adopted it as a cheap and effective solution to engine knocking or "pinging". However, by the 1950s, concerns were raised about the toxic effects of lead on human health, and in the 1970s, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) initiated efforts to phase out leaded gasoline. This phase-out was completed in 1996 in the United States, with most other countries following suit by the early 2000s. During this transition period, car manufacturers began designing engines with unleaded fuel in mind.

To address this issue, engineers introduced hardened valve seats, which are more resilient to valve recession. These hardened valve seats are designed to withstand the high temperatures and pressures present in the combustion chamber, preventing the formation of microwelds. This innovation made unleaded gasoline a viable alternative to leaded fuel, as it eliminated the risk of engine damage associated with the former.

The introduction of hardened valve seats played a crucial role in the shift towards unleaded fuel, ensuring that engines could operate efficiently and safely without the need for lead. This development not only improved engine performance but also contributed to the reduction of toxic lead emissions, benefiting both automotive technology and public health.

While the use of leaded fuel in road vehicles has been successfully phased out, it is still permitted in certain applications, such as aviation, motorsport, and off-road vehicles. However, ongoing efforts are being made to find alternative solutions for these sectors, with the ultimate goal of eliminating leaded fuel completely.

Lead substitutes are available for classic car owners

Classic car owners may be concerned about the effects of modern fuel on their vehicles, especially if their engines are original and use stock valve seats. However, lead substitutes are available and can offer peace of mind that your classic car's engine is protected.

In the 1920s, car manufacturers sought a substance to prevent engine pre-detonation (knocking or pinging). They settled on Tetraethyllead (TEL), which massively raised the octane levels of gasoline and needed to be used once engines in the late 1950s started to ramp up compression ratios. TEL also minimised wear and tear on car valves and valve seats by reducing microwelds.

The Problems with Leaded Fuel

By the 1950s, people began to understand the toxic effects of lead, and in the 1970s, the creation of the EPA led to action being taken against its use. Leaded fuel was found to pose health and environmental hazards and was also incompatible with catalytic converters.

The Move to Unleaded Fuel

By the mid-1970s, most vehicles were being manufactured to accommodate unleaded fuel. This was achieved through the use of hardened, more durable valve seats that could better resist the effects of high temperatures responsible for microwelds.

This is a matter of debate. Many classic cars are not driven much or hard, so some machinists and engine rebuilders argue that hardened valve seats are unnecessary. However, others insist that hardened seats should be added when rebuilding an older engine.

In the meantime, lead substitutes can be used to help protect the engine. These substitutes contain chemicals that form a sacrificial layer to inhibit microwelds and protect valve seats. They are easily available at parts stores or online.

Octane Ratings

Classic car owners should also be aware of the octane rating of the fuel they use. Engines with higher compression ratios typically put out more power and require higher-octane gas. Using fuel with too low an octane rating can cause pre-ignition, disrupting engine timing, reducing power, and potentially damaging the engine.

While not essential, lead substitutes can be beneficial for classic car owners, especially those with original engines and stock valve seats. These substitutes can help prevent valve issues and engine damage, and provide peace of mind for classic car enthusiasts.

Methylcyclopentadienyl manganese tricarbonyl (MMT) is a metallic additive used in lead substitutes

Methylcyclopentadienyl manganese tricarbonyl (MMT) is a metallic additive used in leaded and unleaded gasoline as a substitute for lead. MMT was initially marketed as a supplement for leaded gasoline and was later used in unleaded gasoline to increase the octane rating.

MMT is an organomanganese compound with the formula (C5H4CH3)Mn(CO)3. When burned, it forms manganese particles. Combustion of gasoline containing MMT releases submicron particles of Mn3O4, which may penetrate deeply into the bronchial areas of the respiratory system. High exposure to airborne manganese has been associated with severe neurotoxic effects.

The use of MMT as a fuel additive has been controversial due to health concerns and its impact on catalytic converters. Manganese compounds have very low toxicity, but their combustion products can irreversibly damage catalytic converters. In the United States, MMT was used alongside tetraethyl lead (TEL) after the implementation of the Clean Air Act in 1970. TEL was phased out and banned from US gasoline in 1995.

Despite the controversy and health concerns, MMT has been used in Canadian gasoline since 1976 and was introduced in Australia in 2000. It has also been used in China and other countries. The use of MMT is currently allowed in the US for unleaded gasoline, excluding reformulated gasoline, at a specific treat rate.

The phase-out of leaded fuel has had a positive impact on violent crime rates

The phase-out of leaded fuel has been linked to a significant reduction in violent crime rates, particularly in the 1990s. Lead, a toxic metal, was historically used as an additive in gasoline to reduce engine knocking and pinging. However, concerns about its toxicity emerged in the 1950s, and by the 1970s, the dangers of lead exposure were widely recognized. The state of California banned leaded fuel in 1992, and other states soon followed suit. This marked the beginning of the end for leaded gasoline in the US.

The link between lead exposure and crime was first established by economist Rick Nevin, who found a strong correlation between lead emissions from automobiles and violent crime rates. Nevin discovered that lead emissions rose steadily from the 1940s to the 1970s before plummeting due to the introduction of unleaded gasoline. Interestingly, violent crime rates followed a similar pattern, with a time lag of about 20 years. This suggests that toddlers exposed to high lead levels in the 1940s and 1950s were more likely to become violent criminals in the 1960s, 1970s, and 1980s.

Subsequent studies have further supported the link between lead exposure and violent crime. Jessica Wolpaw Reyes, a public health policy professor at Amherst, found that states with slower declines in leaded gasoline consumption experienced slower declines in crime rates. Additionally, a 2017 study by Anna Aizer and Janet Currie found that lead exposure in childhood increased school suspensions and juvenile detention among boys, providing further evidence that the phase-out of leaded fuel contributed to the decline in crime rates.

Frequently asked questions