Charging An Ev Vs Filling An Ice Tank: Cost Comparison

how much to charge ev vs fuel ice

The cost of charging an electric vehicle (EV) versus fuelling an internal combustion engine (ICE) vehicle is a highly debated topic. While EV aficionados advocate for lower running costs, skeptics point out the higher upfront cost of EVs. The true cost of ownership depends on various factors, including driving habits, vehicle class, and fuel prices. This paragraph will delve into these factors to provide a comprehensive understanding of the costs associated with EVs and ICE vehicles.

shunfuel

The cost of electricity vs. gasoline

The cost of electricity versus gasoline has been a key consideration for consumers when deciding between purchasing an electric vehicle (EV) and a traditional internal combustion engine (ICE) car. While EVs generally have a higher purchase price, they are often cheaper to run and maintain in the long term.

According to US government data, the monthly cost of charging an EV is $70.72, compared to $158 to fuel an ICE car. These calculations are based on various factors, including fuel economy, miles driven, and the cost of electricity and gasoline. However, it is important to note that these costs can vary depending on individual usage and regional electricity and fuel prices.

Public EV charging infrastructure costs can be significantly higher and may reduce the potential savings of choosing an EV over an ICE vehicle. The availability and reliability of public charging stations can also impact the convenience and practicality of owning an EV. Some consumers have also reported that the cost of installing a home EV charger negated any potential savings. In contrast, gasoline vehicles are subject to volatile fuel prices, which can fluctuate and impact refuelling costs.

The type of vehicle also plays a role in the cost comparison. For example, luxury EVs charged mostly at home are generally less expensive to fuel than comparable ICE vehicles. On the other hand, entry-priced and mid-priced ICE cars tend to be more economical to fuel than their EV counterparts, especially when charged at commercial stations.

Depreciation is another factor to consider. EVs tend to depreciate more quickly than gasoline vehicles, which can impact their resale value and overall cost of ownership. However, EV owners may be eligible for tax credits or incentives that can offset some of these costs.

In summary, while electricity costs are generally cheaper than gasoline, the overall cost comparison between EVs and ICE cars depends on various factors, including vehicle type, charging infrastructure, regional prices, and depreciation rates. Consumers should carefully consider these factors when making a decision to understand the true cost of ownership.

shunfuel

Public vs. at-home charging

Public charging stations are available to anyone who needs to charge their electric vehicle (EV) on the go. They are often found in shopping centres, workplaces, and along highways. However, they usually come with a fee, and the rates vary depending on the network and location. For example, a full charge on a 40kW battery costs $8 to $10 for Level 2 charging and $16 to $24 for Fast DC charging. A public Level 2 charging station typically costs $1 to $5 an hour, translating to $0.20 to $0.25 per kWh.

On the other hand, at-home charging stations are installed where you live, and you only need to pay for the electricity used. At-home charging remains the most affordable way to charge an EV, with a price difference of at least $0.04 per kWh when compared to public Level 2 charging. With an average electricity rate of $0.17/kWh, adding 100 kWh to an EV battery costs an average of $17. With an average battery size of 40 kWh, a full charge costs $6.80 by recharging at home.

The cost of charging an EV at home or at a public station depends on several factors, such as the make and model of the EV, electricity rates, and usage patterns. For example, at-home charging may not be feasible for those who live in apartments or rented spaces without charging infrastructure. In contrast, public charging stations can be more expensive but offer faster charging options, which may be more convenient for those in a hurry.

According to calculations based on US driving averages, the monthly cost of charging an EV is $70.72, compared to $158 to fuel an internal combustion engine (ICE) car. This translates to an estimated savings of $950 a year for EV drivers compared to their ICE counterparts.

shunfuel

Running costs

Public charging infrastructure for EVs can be unreliable and expensive, with prices fluctuating depending on the network and location. Relying solely on public charging can significantly increase EV running costs, sometimes making them higher than ICE vehicles. In contrast, at-home charging is generally more cost-effective, and most EV charging occurs at home or at the workplace, according to a 2021 study. However, installing a home EV charger can be costly and may negate any savings.

The cost of electricity and gasoline varies across different locations, with some regions having lower EV ownership rates and cheaper gasoline prices. Additionally, EVs are subject to state taxes, transmission losses during recharging, and the cost of driving to distant public charging stations, which can tip the balance towards gasoline cars in certain scenarios.

Depreciation is another factor affecting running costs. EVs tend to depreciate faster than ICE vehicles, contributing to their higher overall ownership costs. However, EV owners may be eligible for tax credits or incentives that can offset these costs.

Overall, while EVs typically offer lower running costs due to cheaper electricity prices, the specific circumstances, driving habits, and regional factors will impact the overall running costs of both EV and ICE vehicles.

shunfuel

Maintenance costs

Firstly, fuel costs are generally lower for EVs compared to ICE vehicles. Based on US averages, the monthly cost of charging an EV is approximately $70.72, while the cost of fuelling an ICE car is $158. This difference is significant and contributes to the lower maintenance costs associated with EVs. However, it is important to note that public EV charging infrastructure can be expensive and unreliable, affecting the overall maintenance costs. Some individuals have also mentioned that the cost of installing a home EV charger can offset the savings made on fuel costs.

Secondly, vehicle depreciation plays a crucial role in maintenance costs. EVs tend to depreciate faster than their ICE counterparts due to various factors, including customer demand, brand reputation, and higher upfront costs. This steeper depreciation curve can impact the overall maintenance and ownership costs of EVs.

Additionally, insurance costs for EVs are currently higher than for ICE vehicles. This is a factor that can influence the overall maintenance expenses, especially for luxury EVs or when considering the total cost of ownership, including insurance and maintenance.

Servicing costs for EVs and ICE vehicles can also vary. Some car brands have similar servicing prices and intervals for EVs and ICE models, even though EVs have fewer moving parts. However, this may differ depending on the specific car brand and model.

Lastly, the availability of charging infrastructure can impact maintenance costs. In regions with lower EV ownership rates, such as the Midwest in the United States, chargers may not be readily available, making refueling at home or accessing commercial charging stations more challenging. This can influence the overall maintenance costs for EVs in such regions.

In summary, while EVs generally have lower fuel costs compared to ICE vehicles, other factors such as depreciation, insurance, servicing, and the availability of charging infrastructure can impact the overall maintenance expenses. These factors can vary depending on the specific vehicle, location, and driving habits, making it essential to consider multiple aspects when comparing maintenance costs between EVs and ICE vehicles.

shunfuel

Depreciation

Electric vehicles (EVs) have historically depreciated faster than internal combustion engine (ICE) vehicles, mainly due to concerns over battery life and technology becoming obsolete. However, this gap is closing, and EVs are expected to match the depreciation level of ICE vehicles over time.

According to data from 2024, the depreciation rate for ICE vehicles is $0.11–$0.12 per mile, or 0.5% per 1,000 miles, resulting in a loss of around 40% of their value after 100,000 miles. In comparison, EVs depreciate at a rate of $0.27 per mile, or 0.75% per 1,000 miles, leading to a 50% loss in value after the same distance. The higher depreciation rate for EVs is influenced by factors such as battery health, remaining capacity, brand, model, and modifications.

Several factors contribute to the narrowing gap in depreciation rates between EVs and ICE vehicles. Firstly, advancements in battery technology have improved the resale value of EVs. Secondly, the increasing availability of public charging infrastructure has made EVs more convenient and attractive to buyers. Lastly, growing consumer acceptance of EVs has also played a role in enhancing their resale value.

It is worth noting that certain EVs, such as high-performance electric cars like the Porsche Taycan, depreciate at a lower rate than the average fuel-powered car. Additionally, the upcoming ban on new ICE car sales in 2035 may further influence the depreciation rates and resale values of both EV and ICE vehicles.

While depreciation is an important consideration when purchasing a vehicle, it is not the only factor. The lower running costs of EVs compared to ICE vehicles can offset some of the depreciation impact. Additionally, factors such as mileage, wear and tear, and maintenance needs can also affect the overall value of a vehicle over time.

Frequently asked questions

The cost of charging an EV at home depends on the electricity rates in your area. For example, in Australia, the off-peak overnight electricity tariff is $0.30 per kWh.

The cost of charging an EV in public can vary depending on the network and station. In Australia, the DC fast-charging station costs $0.50 per kWh. In the US, public charging stations can cost around $13 to $16 for every 100 miles.

The cost of fueling an ICE car depends on the vehicle's fuel economy and the price of gasoline. In the US, the average monthly cost of fueling an ICE car is $158. In Michigan, mid-priced ICE vehicles cost around $11.61 per 100 miles.

It depends on various factors such as electricity and gasoline prices, vehicle efficiency, and charging infrastructure. Generally, it is cheaper to charge an EV than to fuel an ICE car, especially when charging at home. However, public charging costs for EVs can be high and may negate any savings.

Other factors to consider include the purchase price, depreciation, insurance, maintenance costs, and tax credits or incentives for EVs. EVs tend to have higher purchase prices and depreciate more quickly than ICE cars. However, EVs may have lower maintenance costs and qualify for tax credits, which can offset some of the upfront costs.

Written by
Reviewed by

Explore related products

Share this post
Print
Did this article help you?

Leave a comment