Fossil Fuel Costs: A Historical Perspective On Price Changes

Fossil fuel costs have been volatile, with prices fluctuating in response to geopolitical conflicts, such as Russia's invasion of Ukraine, and climate-related disruptions. Fossil fuel prices impact not only the cost of energy services but also non-energy items. The volatility of fossil fuel prices has contributed significantly to inflation, affecting essential areas like food, shelter, and energy. The true costs of fossil fuels extend beyond their market price, encompassing externalities such as pollution, land degradation, health issues, and environmental degradation. The transition to renewable energy sources can help stabilise prices and reduce overall emissions, but it requires significant investment in infrastructure and supportive policies from governments.

Fossil fuel prices are volatile and impact the price of energy services and non-energy items

Fossil fuel prices are volatile, and this volatility has a significant impact on the price of energy services and non-energy items. Fossil fuel prices are tied to international oil and gas markets, which are influenced by various factors such as commodity cycles, geopolitical interference, and imbalances between supply and demand. This volatility has far-reaching consequences, affecting not only the price at the pump and heating bills but also the cost of everyday necessities such as food, clothing, and shelter.

In recent years, fossil fuel and energy prices have contributed to record-high inflation in countries like Canada and the United States. Between February 2021 and June 2022, energy price increases accounted for a third of Canada's overall inflation. In the US, energy prices contributed to a 40-year high in inflation, with a third of that inflation attributed to energy prices. This has sparked conversations about the inadequacy of monetary policy tools to manage price stability.

The volatility of fossil fuel prices presents a persistent threat to macroeconomic price stability. Transitioning to more stable, electrified, and renewable energy sources is crucial for slowing climate change and achieving long-term price stability. A well-managed and rapid divestment from fossil fuels is necessary to eliminate the inherent volatility in the energy sector.

Up to 25% of non-energy items within the Consumer Price Index are sensitive to oil prices. These include food, goods, services, and costs for both owned and rented shelter. The impact of fluctuating fossil fuel prices on these items underscores the far-reaching consequences of energy price volatility.

Moreover, the hidden costs of fossil fuels, such as externalities like pollution, land degradation, health issues, and environmental degradation, are not always reflected in their market price. These externalities have serious impacts on public health, local communities, ecosystems, and the global climate. For example, the burning of fossil fuels releases toxins and global warming emissions, contributing to respiratory and cardiovascular ailments, as well as global warming.

In summary, the volatility of fossil fuel prices has significant economic and societal implications, affecting both the price of energy services and non-energy items. Addressing this volatility through a transition to renewable energy sources is essential for mitigating climate change and improving price stability.

Fossil fuel price volatility is driven by geopolitical conflicts, climate-related disruptions, and integration of regional natural gas markets with global LNG markets

Fossil fuel price volatility is influenced by a combination of geopolitical conflicts, climate-related disruptions, and the integration of regional natural gas markets with global LNG markets.

Geopolitical tensions and conflicts have a significant impact on fossil fuel prices. For instance, the war in Ukraine and rising tensions in the Middle East have led to large movements in oil and gas prices, with oil prices increasing significantly since the end of the pandemic. Conflicts and tensions can affect the supply of fossil fuels, creating uncertainty and putting upward pressure on prices.

Climate change also plays a crucial role in fossil fuel price volatility. The nexus between climate change and fossil fuel prices is complex, with climate-related disruptions influencing energy consumption and the energy structure. Extreme temperatures, for example, can lead to increased energy consumption, while natural disasters can impact energy infrastructure and production. Additionally, government interventions and policies aimed at addressing climate change can also influence fossil fuel prices.

The integration of regional natural gas markets with global LNG markets further contributes to price volatility. The flexibility of the LNG industry allows for the redirection of shipments to different markets, depending on demand. This dynamic can lead to supply disruptions and price fluctuations, particularly in times of high demand or geopolitical tensions.

Moreover, the transition towards cleaner energy sources and the implementation of decarbonization policies by major gas buyers can also impact fossil fuel prices. As countries shift towards renewable energy technologies and energy efficiency measures, the demand for fossil fuels may decrease, affecting the profitability of fossil fuel projects and investments.

Overall, the interplay between these factors creates a complex and dynamic environment that influences fossil fuel price volatility. The effects of these factors are interrelated and can vary over time, making it challenging to predict the exact impact on fossil fuel prices.

Fossil fuel prices are susceptible to large fluctuations, making energy prices the most volatile component of overall inflation

Fossil fuel prices are susceptible to large fluctuations due to various factors, making energy prices the most volatile component of overall inflation. This volatility has significant economic implications and can impact not only the price of energy services but also many non-energy items.

One key factor contributing to the volatile nature of fossil fuel prices is their dependence on international markets. Oil and gas prices are determined by global supply and demand, which can be influenced by geopolitical conflicts, climate-related disruptions, and the integration of regional markets with global markets. For example, conflicts in the Middle East and Russia's invasion of Ukraine have contributed to price volatility. Additionally, climate change and extreme weather events can disrupt infrastructure, supply, and demand, leading to price fluctuations.

Another factor affecting fossil fuel price volatility is the impact of geopolitical tensions and market disruptions. Historical data shows that major oil price shocks have often coincided with supply disruptions caused by political events. For instance, the Arab Oil Embargo in the 1970s and more recent disruptions in countries like Nigeria, Venezuela, and Iran have influenced oil prices. Market participants constantly assess the possibility of future disruptions, considering factors such as the size and duration of potential disruptions and the availability of crude stocks. This uncertainty can lead to higher volatility in prices.

The low responsiveness of both supply and demand to price changes in the short run also contributes to fossil fuel price volatility. It takes time to develop new supply sources or vary production, and consumers face challenges in switching to alternative fuels or improving fuel efficiency immediately when prices rise. As a result, a significant price change may be necessary to rebalance the physical supply and demand following a shock to the system.

Additionally, fossil fuel prices are influenced by economic events and trends. For example, the COVID-19 pandemic led to a decrease in demand and a sharp drop in oil prices. In contrast, the post-pandemic recovery phase saw a rapid increase in energy demand, particularly in key OPEC-plus countries, contributing to skyrocketing international oil and gas prices.

The impact of volatile fossil fuel prices on inflation is significant. In Canada, for instance, energy prices accounted for a third (33%) of overall inflation from February 2021 to June 2022. This volatility has far-reaching consequences, affecting transportation, home heating, and power costs. Additionally, non-energy items, such as food, durable goods, and services, are also impacted by oil and gas price changes, contributing to overall inflation.

To mitigate the impact of volatile fossil fuel prices on inflation and improve price stability, a transition to renewable and electrified energy sources is necessary. Government policies that discourage fossil fuel use, such as carbon pricing, fuel taxation, and subsidy reforms, are crucial. Additionally, investments in reliable, efficient, and low-cost energy sources can help stabilize prices and reduce the economy's exposure to volatile fossil fuel markets.

Fossil fuel price volatility is expected to continue and worsen as climate-related disruptions impact infrastructure, supply, and demand

For example, the polar vortex of 2021, which reached as far south as Texas and the Gulf of Mexico, brought winter storms to regions unprepared for freezing temperatures. The heavy reliance on natural gas in Texas meant that frozen equipment restricted gas transmission, and extreme cold shut down 25 refineries in the Gulf of Mexico region. This increased demand and reduced supply led to gas price spikes in Texas and throughout North America, including Canada.

Similarly, the Canadian wildfires of 2016 and 2023 impacted North American oil prices. Lowered production levels caused oil prices to surge, although they fell again when production recovered. Wildfires disrupting the oil sands can also create price volatility in the opposite direction. Alberta oil sands operations account for more than 25% of Canadian natural gas demand, and when that demand is disrupted, intra-Alberta natural gas prices drop.

As global demand for fossil fuels declines, market responses, geopolitics, and potential imbalances in supply and demand could increase price volatility. Ongoing geopolitical tensions and lower levels of global cooperation further increase the risk of market disruptions and price shocks.

To mitigate the impact of inevitable global fossil fuel price fluctuations, investment in reliable, efficient, and low-cost energy sources is essential. Transitioning energy systems away from fossil fuels can insulate against volatile fossil fuel prices and energy-driven inflation, reduce energy use, and lower emissions.

Fossil fuel prices can be stabilised by transitioning to renewable energy sources, which have become more cost-effective

Renewable energy sources such as wind, solar, and hydropower are cheaper to operate than fossil fuels because they do not require fuel. Fossil fuels, on the other hand, require fuel such as coal, oil, and natural gas, which can be expensive to extract, transport, and store. The cost of fuel for fossil fuels can also fluctuate, making it difficult to predict operating costs. In contrast, renewable energy sources have no fuel costs, making them more predictable and less volatile. This makes renewable energy more attractive to consumers and can drive down the price of fossil fuels.

The transition to renewable energy sources has been accelerated by advancements in technology, which have made these sources more efficient. For example, solar panels are now more efficient at converting sunlight into electricity, and wind turbines are more efficient at capturing wind energy. This increased efficiency means that renewable energy sources can generate more electricity at a lower cost, further reducing the demand for fossil fuels.

In addition to the economic benefits of renewable energy, it is important to consider the environmental costs of fossil fuels. Fossil fuels have significant environmental impacts, including air pollution, water pollution, and greenhouse gas emissions, which are not reflected in their price. These costs can have significant economic and health consequences for society. Renewable energy, on the other hand, has much lower environmental costs, making it a more attractive option from a societal standpoint.

Government incentives, such as tax credits, subsidies, and grants, have also played a role in the transition to renewable energy. These incentives help offset the initial costs of installing renewable energy systems, making them more affordable for businesses and individuals. As a result, the demand for renewable energy has increased, leading to greater competition among renewable energy providers, which has driven down costs. In some cases, renewable energy is now cheaper than fossil fuels even without government incentives.

The transition to renewable energy is crucial for reducing our reliance on fossil fuels and mitigating climate change. Fossil fuels are the largest contributor to global climate change, accounting for over 75% of global greenhouse gas emissions. By transitioning to renewable energy sources, we can reduce emissions and work towards achieving net-zero emissions by 2050.

Frequently asked questions